A Summary and Background of the Federal Tax Credit Scholarship Program

Posted · Add Comment

Earlier this week, Governor Mikie Sherrill co-signed a letter to Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent asking for clarification on several items regarding the federal tax credit scholarship program, more commonly referred to as the federal voucher program. NJPSA staff hopes that the following summary provides a helpful starting point for our members to understand this important issue.

Background

The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (Public Law 119-21) was signed into law on July 4, 2025. Within that document, Section 70411 established the first “federal tax credit scholarship program” for elementary and secondary education, to become effective January 1, 2027. Although it is established as a scholarship program funded by tax credits (and referred to specifically as a scholarship program), numerous national and New Jersey public school advocacy organizations recognize it, and have referred to it, as a voucher program. 

Before this law, school voucher and scholarship tax-credit programs primarily operated at the state level. This new program draws on the existing model used in many of those states: individuals donate to nonprofit scholarship-granting organizations (SGOs) and receive a federal tax credit for qualifying contributions. The SGOs then award scholarships to eligible students. 

Terms of the Program

  • The tax credit: Beginning in tax year 2027, individual U.S. taxpayers can claim a nonrefundable federal income tax credit of up to $1,700 per taxpayer per year for qualifying cash contributions to eligible SGOs. Unused credit generally may be carried forward for up to five years. 
  • State participation: Participation is voluntary. A state or the District of Columbia must elect to participate and identify qualifying SGOs to the federal government. The program does not automatically operate in every state. The state takes on significant administrative responsibilities but is strictly limited in its ability to modify, adjust or adapt the terms and conditions of the program. 
  • Student eligibility: Scholarships are available to students eligible to enroll in public elementary or secondary school whose household income is below 300% of the area’s median gross income. New Jersey’s median income is somewhere between $104,000 and $111,000 depending on the source, meaning the income limit is over $300,000 for this program. 
  • Eligible organizations: SGOs must be qualifying tax-exempt nonprofit organizations, not private foundations, and must devote “substantially all” their activities to providing eligible educational scholarships. They generally must spend at least 90% of their income on scholarships. 
  • Permitted expenses: Scholarship funds may cover tuition, fees, books, supplies, equipment, tutoring, and certain special-needs services. They may also cover qualifying school-related room and board, uniforms, transportation, and computer technology or internet access. Scholarships are excluded from recipients’ federal gross income. 
  • Award priorities: SGOs must prioritize students who received scholarships in prior years, followed by siblings of those students, before awarding scholarships to other eligible students. 
  • Tax limitations: The credit is nonrefundable, so it cannot generate a refund beyond the taxpayer’s tax liability. The federal credit is reduced by any state tax credit received for the same contribution, and a contribution claimed for this credit cannot also be claimed as a charitable deduction. 

Implementation and Significance

The program is scheduled to begin January 1, 2027, and the U.S. Treasury Department and IRS have begun establishing participation procedures for states and qualifying scholarship organizations. At the time of this writing, 31 states have opted in, two have explicitly declined to participate, two have Governors who rejected legislation opting in, and the remaining 16 (including Washington D.C.) have not made a decision. 

New Jersey, as one of the latter states, has until the end of December in order to decide whether or not to participate. The decision to do so lies with the Governor, and her administration has reached out to numerous advocacy organizations for thoughts and perspectives on the potential impacts of participation as well as opting out. 

After extensive review and discussion, NJPSA shared its concerns, which are significant, and recommended that the Governor not to opt New Jersey into this voucher program at this time. That document may be viewed here. 

As noted above, Governor Sherrill is co-signor of a letter to the Secretary of the Treasury asking for clarification on a number of questions, including several concerns raised by NJPSA in its communication to her. Based on guidance issued and public statements made to this point, it is unlikely that the Secretary’s response will provide information that impacts or changes our own recommendation, but we look forward to considering it, as we hope it does provide clarity on the administration’s intent toward public funding of our schools going forward. We remain ready should the Governor require any additional information or guidance in making her final decision. 

We hope this document provides you with a better understanding of this issue and the discussion around it in our state. Please do not hesitate to reach out to Debbie, Jennie, or Chris if you have any questions or if we can be of any further assistance.